Using brain images of people listening to short symphonies by an obscure 18th-century composer, a research team from the Stanford University School of Medicine has gained valuable insight into how the brain sorts out the chaotic world around it.
The research team showed that music engages the areas of the brain involved with paying attention, making predictions and updating the event in memory. Peak brain activity occurred during a short period of silence between musical movements - when seemingly nothing was happening.
Beyond understanding the process of listening to music, their work has far-reaching implications for how human brains sort out events in general.
The researchers caught glimpses of the brain in action using functional magnetic resonance imaging, or fMRI, which gives a dynamic image showing which parts of the brain are working during a given activity. The goal of the study was to look at how the brain sorts out events, but the research also revealed that musical techniques used by composers 200 years ago help the brain organize incoming information.
"In a concert setting, for example, different individuals listen to a piece of music with wandering attention, but at the transition point between movements, their attention is arrested," said the paper‘s senior author Vinod Menon, PhD, associate professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences and of neurosciences.
"I‘m not sure if the baroque composers would have thought of it in this way, but certainly from a modern neuroscience perspective, our study shows that this is a moment when individual brains respond in a tightly synchronized manner," Menon said.
The team used music to help study the brain‘s attempt to make sense of the continual flow of information the real world generates, a process called event segmentation. The brain partitions information into meaningful chunks by extracting information about beginnings, endings and the boundaries between events.
"These transitions between musical movements offer an ideal setting to study the dynamically changing landscape of activity in the brain during this segmentation process," said Devarajan Sridharan, a neurosciences graduate student trained in Indian percussion and first author of the article.
No previous study, to the researchers�knowledge, has directly addressed the question of event segmentation in the act of hearing and, specifically, in music. To explore this area, the team chose pieces of music that contained several movements, which are self-contained sections that break a single work into segments. They chose eight symphonies by the English late-baroque period composer William Boyce (1711-79), because his music has a familiar style but is not widely recognized, and it contains several well-defined transitions between relatively short movements.
The study focused on movement transitions - when the music slows down, is punctuated by a brief silence and begins the next movement. These transitions span a few seconds and are obvious to even a non-musician - an aspect critical to their study, which was limited to participants with no formal music training.
The researchers attempted to mimic the everyday activity of listening to music, while their subjects were lying prone inside the large, noisy chamber of an MRI machine. Ten men and eight women entered the MRI scanner with noise-reducing headphones, with instructions to simply listen passively to the music.
In the analysis of the participants�brain scans, the researchers focused on a 10-second window before and after the transition between movements. They identified two distinct neural networks involved in processing the movement transition, located in two separate areas of the brain. They found what they called a "striking" difference between activity levels in the right and left sides of the brain during the entire transition, with the right side significantly more active.
In this foundational study, the researchers conclude that dynamic changes seen in the fMRI scans reflect the brain‘s evolving responses to different phases of a symphony. An event change - the movement transition signaled by the termination of one movement, a brief pause, followed by the initiation of a new movement - activates the first network, called the ventral fronto-temporal network. Then a second network, the dorsal fronto-parietal network, turns the spotlight of attention to the change and, upon the next event beginning, updates working memory.
"The study suggests one possible adaptive evolutionary purpose of music," said Jonathan Berger, PhD, professor of music and a musician who is another co-author of the study. Music engages the brain over a period of time, he said, and the process of listening to music could be a way that the brain sharpens its ability to anticipate events and sustain attention.
According to the researchers, their findings expand on previous functional brain imaging studies of anticipation, which is at the heart of the musical experience. Even non-musicians are actively engaged, at least subconsciously, in tracking the ongoing development of a musical piece, and forming predictions about what will come next. Typically in music, when something will come next is known, because of the music‘s underlying pulse or rhythm, but what will occur next is less known, they said.
Having a mismatch between what listeners expect to hear vs. what they actually hear - for example, if an unrelated chord follows an ongoing harmony - triggers similar ventral regions of the brain. Once activated, that region partitions the deviant chord as a different segment with distinct boundaries.
The results of the study "may put us closer to solving the cocktail party problem - how it is that we are able to follow one conversation in a crowded room of many conversations," said one of the co-authors, Daniel Levitin, PhD, associate professor of psychology and music from McGill University, who has written a popular book called This Is Your Brain on Music: The Science of a Human Obsession.
These findings will be published in the Aug. 2 issue of Neuron.
斯妼›å¤§å¦åŒ»å¦é™¢çš„ç ”½I¶äh员利用大脑æˆåƒæŠ€æœ¯ï¼Œç ”究 18 世纪一ä½äh们ä¸å¤ªç†Ÿæ‚(zh¨¨n)‰çš„作曲家的交å“ä¹å¯¹å¬ä¼—大脑的媄å“，对大脑如何从周围æ‚äؕ的世界ä¸èŽ·å¾—有æ„义的信毘q™ä¸€é—®é¢˜åQŒèŽ·å¾—了有äh(hu¨¢n)值的ç†è§£ã€?
è¯¥ç ”½I¶å›¢é˜Ÿå‘现音ä¹åª„å“大脑涉åŠæ³¨æ„力ã€é¢„期和更新记忆的区域。大脑的‹zÕdŠ¨é«˜å³°å‘生在音ä¹æ®µè½ä¹‹é—´çŸæš‚çš„åœé¡¿æœŸï¼Œ˜q™æ®µæ—‰™—´è¡¨é¢ä¸Šä¼¼ä¹Žä»€ä¹ˆä¹Ÿæ²¡å‘生ã€?
除ç†è§£å¤§è„‘å¬éŸ³ä¹çš„过½E‹ä¹‹å¤–，他们的工作对ç†è§£äººç±»å¤§è„‘在一般情况下如何获得有æ„义的信毘q™ä¸€é—®é¢˜å…ähœ‰æ·Þp¿œçš„æ„义ã€?
ç ”ç©¶è€…é€šè¿‡åŠŸèƒ½æ ¸ç£å…±æŒ¯æˆåƒæŠ€æœ¯ï¼ˆfMRIåQ‰è§‚察活动ä¸çš„å¤§è„‘ã€‚ç ”½I¶è€…利用该技术能够获得在指定的活动过½E‹ä¸å¤§è„‘的动æ€å›¾åƒï¼Œä»¥ç¡®å®šå¤§è„‘çš„‹zÕdŠ¨åŒºåŸŸã€‚该™å¹ç ”½I¶çš„目的是了解大脑如何ç†è§£å¤–界事ä»Óž¼ŒåŒæ—¶åQŒç ”½I¶ä¹Ÿå‘现 200 òq´å‰ä½œæ›²å®‰™‡‡ç”¨çš„音ä¹æŠ€å·§æœ‰åŠ©äºŽå¤§è„‘¾l„织æ¥è‡ªå¤–界的信æ¯ã€?
“在音ä¹åŽ…里åQŒæ¯ä¸ªå¬ä¼—欣èµéŸ³ä¹æ—¶çš„注æ„力都是游移的，但是在音ä¹æ®µè½ä¹‹é—´çš„åœé¡¿æœŸï¼Œä»–们的注æ„力被å¸å¼•äº†åQŒâ€?æ–‡ç« çš„ä¸»è¦ä½œè€?Vinod Menon åšå£«è¯ß_¼Œä»–是¾_„¡¥žç—…与行äØ“¿U‘å¦ä»¥åŠ¼œžç»¿U‘å¦å‰¯æ•™æŽˆã€?
“我ä¸çŸ¥é“å·´‹z›å…‹é£Žæ ¼çš„作曲家是å¦æœ‰æ„ä¸ÞZ¹‹åQŒä½†æ˜¯ä»ŽçŽîC»£¼œžç»¿U‘å¦çš„观ç‚ÒŽ(gu¨©)¥çœ‹ç¡®å®šæ— ç–‘ï¼Œæˆ‘ä»¬çš„ç ”½I¶è¡¨æ˜Žï¼Œ˜q™ä¸€æ—¶åˆ»ä¸åŒå¬ä¼—的大脑以一¿U密切åŒæ¥çš„æ–¹å¼ä½œå‡ºå应åQŒâ€?Menon 说ã€?
è¯¥ç ”½I¶å°¾l„利用音ä¹æ¥å¸®åŠ©ç ”究大脑如何赋予现实世界产生的连¾lä¿¡æ¯æµä»¥æ˜Ž¼‹®æ„义。这一˜q‡ç¨‹¿UîCؓ事äšg分割。通过获å–关于开始ã€ç»“æŸå’Œäº‹äšg间分界的信æ¯åQŒå¤§è„‘å°†˜qžç®‹ä¿¡æ¯åˆ†å‰²æˆæœ‰æ„义的片ŒDüc€?
“音ä¹æ®µè½ä¹‹é—´çš„åœé¡¿æœŸæ供了一个ç†æƒ³çš„æœÞZ¼šæ¥ç ”½I¶åœ¨äº‹äšg分割˜q‡ç¨‹ä¸ï¼Œå¤§è„‘‹zÕdŠ¨åŠ¨æ€å˜åŒ–的图景åQŒâ€?¼œžç»¿U‘å¦ç ”究ç”?Devarajan Sridharan è¯ß_¼Œä»–å¦ä¹ 过å°ç¬¬å®‰æ‰“å‡ÖM¹å™¨ï¼Œæ˜¯æ–‡ç« çš„½W¬ä¸€ä½œè€…ã€?
æ®è¯¥™å¹ç ”½I¶çš„¿U‘ç ”äººå‘˜æ‰€çŸ¥ï¼Œæ¤å‰˜q˜æ²¡æœ‰ç ”½I¶è€…ç›´æŽ¥ç ”½I¶å¬è§‰æ´»åŠ¨ä¸åQŒç‰¹åˆ«æ˜¯å¬éŸ³ä¹è¿‡½E‹ä¸çš„事件分割过½E‹ã€‚äؓ了探索该领域åQŒè¯¥¿U‘ç ”ž®ç»„é€‰æ‹©äº†å‡ æ”¯åŒ…å«è‹¥òq²ä¹ç« 的音ä¹åQŒæ¯ŒDµä¹ç« 本íw«åˆåˆ†æˆäº†è‹¥òq²ç‰‡ŒDüc€‚他们选择ç”Þp‹±å›½åŽå·´æ´›å…‹æ—¶æœŸä½œæ›²å®¶ William Boyce (1711-1779) 谱曲的八支交å“ä¹ã€‚å› ä¸ÞZ»–的音ä¹å…·æœ‰å¤§å®¶ç†Ÿæ‚(zh¨¨n)‰çš„é£Žæ ¼ä½†æ˜¯òq¶æœªòq¿æ³›‹¹ä¼ åQŒåŒæ—¶ä¹Ÿå› äؓ他的音ä¹åœ¨å°ŒDµè½ä¹‹é—´å…ähœ‰æ¸…晰的圙å¿æœŸã€?
è¯¥é¡¹ç ”ç©¶å…Ïx³¨éŸ³ä¹ŒDµè½ä¹‹é—´çš„圙å?当音ä¹æ…¢ä¸‹æ¥åQŒæŽ¥ç€æ˜¯çŸæš‚çš„åœé¡¿æœŸï¼Œç„¶åŽåˆå¼€å§‹æ–°çš„段è½ã€‚这些圙å¿æŒ¾lå‡ ¿U’é’ŸåQŒå¯¹äºŽæ²¡æœ‰å—˜q‡éŸ³ä¹è®¾lƒçš„人æ¥è¯´ä¹Ÿæ˜¯éžå¸¸æ˜Žæ˜„¡š„-˜q™å¯¹ä»–ä»¬çš„ç ”½I‰™žå¸¸å…³é”®ï¼Œç ”究对象仅é™äºŽæ²¡æœ‰å—˜q‡æ£å¼éŸ³ä¹è®¾lƒçš„人ã€?
ç ”ç©¶äººå‘˜æƒŒ™¦æ¨¡æ‹Ÿæ—¥å¸¸å¬éŸ³ä¹çš„环境åQŒä»–ä»¬çš„ç ”ç©¶å¯¹è±¡ä¿¯å§åœ¨ä¸€ä¸ªå¤§çš„，充满噪声çš?MRI 机房间里。å个男性和八个å¥Ïx€§å¸¦ç€é™å™ªè€ÏxœºæŽ¥å—了MRI 扫æåQŒåƈ按照指示½Ž€å•è¢«åŠ¨åœ°æŽ¥å—音ä¹ã€?
在分æžå¤§è„‘扫æ图åƒè¿‡½E‹ä¸åQŒç ”½I¶äh员集ä¸ç ”½I‰™Ÿ³ä¹åœ™å¿æœŸå秒和åŽå秒的图åƒã€‚他们找åˆîCº†ä¸¤ä¸ªä¸åŒçš„å› éŸ³ä¹åœé¡¿è€Œäñ”生å应的¼œžç»¾|‘络åQŒåˆ†åˆ«ä½äºŽå¤§è„‘的两个ä¸åŒåŒºåŸŸã€‚在整个åœé¡¿æœŸï¼Œä»–们å‘现大脑左å³åŒºåŸŸ‹zÕdŠ¨¾U§åˆ«æ˜¾è‘—ä¸åŒåQŒå³è¾¹åŒºåŸŸæ›´ä¸ºæ´»è·ƒã€?
在这™å¹åŸº¼‹€ç ”究ä¸ï¼Œç ”究人员认äØ“åQŒåœ¨ fMRI 扫æ囑փä¸çš„动æ€å˜åŒ–åæ˜ äº†å¤§è„‘å¯¹äº¤å“ä¹ä¸åŒŒDµè½ä½œå‡ºçš„动æ€å“应。当æŸä¸ªäº‹äšgå‘生å˜åŒ–- 音ä¹åœé¡¿ - ž®†æ¿€‹zȬ¬ä¸€ä¸ªç½‘¾lœï¼Œ¿UîCؓ背侧é¢å¶-™å¶å¶¾|‘络åQ?ventral fronto-temporal networkåQ‰ã€‚接ç€åQŒç¬¬äºŒä¸ª¾|‘络åQŒç§°ä¸ø™…¹ä¾§é¢é¢žç½‘¾lœï¼ˆ dorsal fronto-parietal networkåQ‰ï¼Œž®†æ³¨æ„力集ä¸äºŽè¿™ä¸€æ”¹å˜åQŒåƈ且在下一事äšg的开始时更新记忆ã€?
“该™å¹ç ”½I¶æå‡ÞZº†éŸ³ä¹çš„一个å¯èƒ½çš„适应演化功能åQŒâ€?Jonathan Berger åšå£«è¯ß_¼Œä»–是音ä¹æ•™æŽˆå…ég½œæ›²å®¶åQŒä¹Ÿæ˜¯è¯¥™å¹ç ”½I¶çš„åˆä½œè€…之一。他è¯ß_¼Œè®©å¤§è„‘沉‹¹¸åœ¨éŸ³ä¹ä¸ä¸€ŒD‰|—¶é—ß_¼Œå¬éŸ³ä¹çš„˜q‡ç¨‹èƒ½å¤ŸåŠ 强大脑预测事äšg和维æŒæ³¨æ„力的能力ã€?
ç ”ç©¶äººå‘˜å£°ç§°åQŒä»–们的å‘现扩展了先å‰æœ‰å…³é¢„期的大脑功能æˆåƒçš„ç ”½IÓž¼Œ˜q™æ˜¯éŸ³ä¹ä½“éªŒçš„æ ¸å¿ƒã€‚å³ä½¿æ²¡æœ‰å—˜q‡æ£è§„音ä¹è®¾lƒçš„人，臛_°‘在潜æ„识里，也会¿U¯æžåŽ»è¿½éšä¹ç« å‘展的轨迹åQŒåƈ且åÅžæˆå¯¹ä¸‹ä¸€ä¸ªçš„音符的预‹¹‹ã€‚他们指出，在欣èµéŸ³ä¹æ—¶åQŒäh们知é“下个音½W¦ä¼šä»€ä¹ˆæ—¶å€™å‡ºçŽŽÍ¼Œå› äؓ音ä¹å…ähœ‰åŸºæœ¬çš„节率，但下一个音½W¦æ˜¯ä»€ä¹ˆäh们å´çŸ¥ä¹‹ç”šå°‘ã€?
如果所预期的和实际å¬åˆ°çš„ä¸åŒšw…-比如åQŒå°†ä¸€ä¸ªä¸ç›¸å…³çš„音½W¦æ’入到一ŒDµå’Œè°çš„音ä¹å½“ä¸-åŒæ ·ä¼šè§¦å‘背侧é¢å?™å¶å¶¾|‘络åQˆå³ä¸Šé¢æ到的第一个网¾lœï¼‰ã€‚一¾l触å‘，该网¾lœä¼šž®†é‚£ä¸ªä¸å调的音½W¦å½’于带有明显边界的å¦å¤–的片ŒDµä¸ã€?
è¯¥é¡¹ç ”ç©¶çš„ç»“æžœå¯èƒ½ä‹É我们˜q›ä¸€æ¥ç†è§£â€œé¸¡ž®ùN…’会问题â€?ä¸ÞZ»€ä¹ˆæˆ‘们能够在一个拥挤åµæ‚的戉K—´˜q›è¡Œè°ˆè¯è€Œä¸ä¼šå—其他äºø™°ˆè¯çš„å½±å“-åˆä½œè€…之一åQŒæ¥è‡?McGill 大å¦å¿ƒç†å¦å’ŒéŸ³ä¹å‰¯æ•™æŽˆï¼Œ Daniel Levitin åšå£«è¯ß_¼Œä»–写˜q‡ä¸€æœ¬ç•…销书《欣èµéŸ³ä¹çš„大脑åQšäؓ什么会瀘qøP¼Ÿã€‹ï¼ˆThis Is Your Brain on Music: The Science of a Human ObsessionåQ‰ã€?
˜q™äº›ç ”究å‘表åœ?007òq?æœ?日出版的《神¾l元》（NeuronåQ‰æ‚志上ã€?
|